Problem 4-65

A voltmeter measures 7.5 volts for vo. What is the resistance of the voltmeter?


NOTE 1: items in blue are not part of original diagram.

NOTE 2: I got somewhat different answers than the book. I worked the problem two different ways and got the same values, so I suspect the book is incorrect.


To solve this problem, I will first find the Thevenin Equivalent connected to terminals a and b, then use voltage division to determine the resistance of the voltmeter.

Although we could determine the Thevenin Equivalent by analyzing the circuit as is, I will do a small amount of circuit reduction first to reduce the number of simultaneous equations to 2. I will use mesh analysis. (Note that nodal analysis would yield 2 equations from the circuit as is, but they would be harder to derive (in my opinion) and harder to simplify.)


First, the circuit reduction. I will reduce the 16 V source and the 4 KW and 6 KW resistors to a single voltage source in series with a resistor.

NOTE: I could have reduced the circuit farther without losing ib, but for students just learning circuit analysis, it is probably better to refrain from combining components involving parameters needed in the analysis, so I will stop the reduction here and determine the Thevenin Equivalent using mesh analysis.

First find voc.

First, define parameter used for dependent source in terms of mesh currents.

ib = i1

Next, express the value of the current source in terms of mesh currents.

0.2 ib = - i2

and substituting for ib gives

0.2 i1 = - i2

or

0.2 i1 + i2 = 0 (Equation 1)

Removing the current source leaves only Mesh 1 around which to write KVL:

2.4 K i1 + 100 i1 + 0.4 + 10 K (i1 - i2) - 9.6 = 0

12.5 K i1 - 10 K i2 = 9.2 (Equation 2)

Solving the two equations yields

i1 = 634.48 mA

i2 = - 126.9 mA

Thus

voc = vo = 10 K (i1 - i2) = 10 K (634.48 m + 126.9 m) = 7.6138 V

Next find isc.

Note that since the 10 KW resistor is shorted out now, it can be removed from the circuit.

 

Express dependent source parameters in terms of mesh currents.

ib = i1

Next, express the value of the current source in terms of mesh currents.

0.2 ib = - i2

and substituting for ib gives

0.2 i1 = - i2

or

0.2 i1 + i2 = 0 (Equation 1)

Removing the current source leaves only Mesh 1 around which to write KVL:

2.4 K i1 + 100 i1 + 0.4 - 9.6 = 0

2.5 K i1 = 9.2 (Equation 2)

Solving the two equations yields

i1 = 3.68 mA

i2 = - 736 mA

so

isc = i1 - i2 = 3.68 mA + 736 mA = 4.416 mA

Thus

RTh = voc / isc = 7.6138 / 4.416 m = 1.7241 KW

and the Thevenin equivalent circuit is


Now, if we connect the resistance of the voltmeter to terminals a and b, we know that the voltage across those terminals is 7.5 volts.

Voltage division yields

7.5 = 7.6138 (Rvm) / (Rvm + 1.7241K)

7.5 (Rvm + 1.7241K) = 7.6138 Rvm

7.5 Rvm + 12.931K = 7.6138 Rvm

0.1138 Rvm = 12.931K

Rvm = 113.63 KW


Part b)

What is the percentage of error in the voltage measurement?

Ideally, the voltage should equal 7.6138 V (the Thevenin Equivalent voltage). The difference in the ideal value and measured value is thus

VD = 7.5 - 7.6138 = - 0.1138 V

Thus the percentage error is

Ev = -0.1138 / 7.6138 X 100% = 1.4924%


Return to ECE 202 Homework Solution Index